21 Reasons not to mine copper in Intag, Ecuador

By Carlos Zorilla, resident of Intag and member of Decoin.

Two decades after the resistance to mining in Intag began against a large-scale mining project, which led to the expulsion of two transnational mining companies and the creation of sustainable alternative, Chile’s mining company Codelco, the world’s largest copper producer, in conjunction with Enami, the Ecuadorian state-owned mining company, is ready to begin exploratory activities in one of the world’s most threatened and biodiverse forests: Intag’s Toisan Range.

I think it disingenuous when companies say “we didn’t know”; or “had we only known”, or even lamer yet: “had the government made it clearer that…” then they try to weasel out of assuming responsibility for their catastrophic economic, social and environmental blunders. This then, is an attempt to draw attention to some of the hurdles Codelco, or any mining company, would face if they tried to open up a mine in Intag.

Studies and more Studies.

To justify their existence in certain projects, mining companies, when they can afford it, hire hot-shot NGO’s to carry out interviews and studies to ascertain popular perception on mining, identify key players, and confirm that they are loved. Then they actually go ahead and base their decisions on the study’s results! Even though they know they are lies at worst, or at best, written to please the funders. As if an area’s complexity and attitudes could be studied in a few days or weeks.

A Brand New Century.

If there’s anyone interested in investing in Intag’s mining project reading this, you probably know- or should know- as all responsible mining companies can attest to (as well as key players like the World Bank), that support from the Executive Branch of government is not nearly enough guarantee a project’s success. You need genuine (not manufactured or self-delusional) social license issued freely, without pressures or intimidation. In fact, national government support is no guarantee at all the project will succeed. So, do NOT bank on the government’s enthusiastic endorsement. You’ll lose. Big time.

I am positive that if most INVESTORS were find out about all the risks and obstacles facing mining in this corner of Ecuador, they would pull out.

This, then, is one more attempt to try to inform of the reality behind the lies and distortions being generated around the Junín mining project, and just 21 of the reasons why this project, as BN Americas pointed out in 2013, is bound to fail.

IMPACTS

Based on the Bishi Metals Environmental Impact Assessment of mining in Intag, and on a small (450,000 ton) copper mine (a couple of years later they inferred the existence of 5x more copper)

  1. Intag is not like the Atacama desert, where Codelco has its copper mines. Besides being super biodiverse, there are communities all over the place. According to the Study, the mining project would relocate hundreds of families from four communities.  Afterwards, the Japanese found more five times more copper, which could increase the number of communities affected by two- at the very least. Relocation of communities is more than enough to stop most extractive projects.
  1. It would impact primary cloud forests.  What’s so special about cloud forests?  Less than 2.5% of the world’s tropical forests are cloud forests. They are not only exceptionally biologically diverse- as well as severely threatened-  but they play an outsize role in protecting important headwater watersheds.
  1. The project would cause massive deforestation(in the words of the experts preparing the Study). The small mine would directly impact 4,025 hectares.
  1. The deforestation, according to the Japanese, would lead to drying of local climate, affecting thousands of small farmers (the EIA used the worddesertification). You think communities will let this happen once they truly get the picture???
  1. Intag’s forests belong to the world’s top Biodiversity Hotspot; the Tropical Andes. The scientist working on the study identified 12 species of mammals and birds facing extinction that would be impacted by the project, including jaguars, spectacled bears, mountain tapirs and the brown-faced spider monkey. (Based on incomplete studies, Decoin identified more than 30 species of threatened or endangered plants and animals, and there could be dozens more).

Every year new species are found in Ecuador’s cloud forests, and this includes the spectacular Prince Charles frog, as well as the only carnivore discovered in the Western Hemisphere in the last 35 years.  In addition, the area has several other endemic species, such as the recently discovered Shape-shifting Rain Frog (Pristimantis mutabilis), and the Black-breasted Puffleg Hummingbird, which exists in only two patches of high altitude cloud forests- one of them located in Intag.

  1. There are pristine rivers and streams everywhere within the concession.  The EIA predicted they would be contaminated with lead, arsenic, chromium, cadmium and other toxic substances.
  1. The project would, unquestionably, destroy pre-Incan Yumbo archeological sites.  This is one of the least studied cultures in Ecuador.

It would impact the Cotacachi-Capayas Ecological Reserve (one of the world’s most biologically diverse protected areas and the only large one in all of western Ecuador).

Besides these very worrying impacts identified in the Study (for a mine a fraction of what it could end up being)…  there are other significant hurdles.

Legal hassles

  1. Large-scale mining would violate the legally-binding Cotacachi County Ecological Ordinance created in 2000.  Only the Constitutional Court can rule on the validity of the Ordinance in light of the new Constitution. And the Court l has not.

Ecuador’s new Constitution demands that communities be consulted before any project impacting their social or natural environment takes place; a Constitutional guarantee that has been disregarded from day one. The Constitution also grants nature rights, and the people right to Sumak Kawsay, or a Good Life (also translatable as Harmonious Life) .  Good luck trying to convince a decent government and world opinion that open pit mining will not violate these two fundamental rights (no matter how obscenely the government decides to define the indigenous concept of a “Good Life”).  Just because a government does its best to distort the Constitution does not mean a future one will do the same.

Waning political support.

  1. One of the things the government likes to underline is that it has the area´s political support. As of February 2014 this is no longer true, as the president’s party, Alianza País, lost badly in local elections in Imbabura province, site of the mining project. In fact, Imbabura was one of the provinces where Mr. Correa’s party lost more municipalities (5 out of 6) than anywhere else in the country.   One of those Municipalities is the Cotacachi, which encompasses the Llurimagua mining concession. The new Mayor, Jomar Cevallos, is firmly opposed to mining.
  1. Opposition.

There is widespread opposition to the Intag mining project. This includes:

  1.  The new threat has actually mobilized more organization at the local, county and national level, than ever before.

Community Opposition. Many communities surrounding the mining project are still, after all these years, opposed to the project. There are some that seemingly have given their approval, though under duress and without any consultation whatsoever taken place. Proof of this is that on September and November 2013 the government tried to carry out an environmental impact study and were stopped by the communities- in spite of heavy police presence, and military in the area.

  1. Human Rights Violations.

After years of stopping dozens of attempts by government and private companies of accessing the mining concession that overlap communal land in order to carry out the environmental impact study and begin exploration, the government and Codelco only succeeded in carrying out the study in May of 2014 with the help of hundreds of police that terrorized the area for two months and violated rights, such as the right to freely circulate. To intensify the intimidation, a month earlier Javier Ramírez, president of the Junín community was arrested and jailed under highly irregular circumstances, which have been denounced by human rights organizations such as Amnesty International, and The International Human Rights Federation, as well as several national human rights groups. Human Rights Watch is currently investigating the numerous human rights violations surrounding the Javier Ramirez case.  Javier was released after being sentenced in February of 2015 but only after serving 10 months in jail. His brother Victor Hugo remains in hiding accused of sabotage, the same criminal offense as his brother, for putting up resistance to the presence of Enami employees in their territory.

  1. 90% of NGO’s in Cotacachi County and Intag oppose the project. In late 2012, the most important civil society organizations in Intag wrote a letter to Chile’s president to make sure he understood that the organizations would again rise to defend the area if Codelco or anyone went ahead and tried to revive the project.  .

 

Exaggerated Copper Claims

15. In 2007, Micon International, the entity contracted by Ascendant Copper to evaluate the Junin copper deposit, said that it could not confirm their earlier estimates due to degradation of samples. Copper Mesa had been saying all along that the Junin copper deposit had four times more copper than what the Japanese inferred after years of exploration.   In all, 2.26 million tons were inferred by the Japanese, which is a little less than 1/10thof what the world consumes annually (and it would take decades to mine it all out).

 

Further environmental challenges

16. The area receives between 3000 and 4000 millimeters of annual rainfall. Heavy rainfall, abundant underground   aquifers, and heavy metals in the ore make for a deadly mix.  Not only that, but they raise the price of mining         considerably, while greatly increasing the risks of man-made disasters, such as landslides.  For an idea of what a   landslide can do in an open pit mine, gohere:

 

  1. The ore contains toxic heavy metals and sulfur (which will cause Acid Mine Drainage).

 

  1. There is a superabundance of underground water (according to Japanese EIA). This is bad news for mining companies and even worse news for the environment.

 

  1. The area where they found the copper is exceptionally steep and mountainous, making mining much more difficult and expensive than most mines.

 

  1. There are clear indications that Junín’s copper is very deep, making mining much more environmentally destructive and economically risky.  Emphasis on Economically risky.

 

  1. The Toisan Range has many geological faults, posing significant earthquake risks.

 

There are, in fact, more than 21 reasons for Codelco to stay out of Intag. But these should suffice for any company that considers itself responsible and to realize that Intag’s forests and inhabitants should be a no-go zone.

 

For more information contact Carlos Zorrilla at Decoin (decointag@gmail.com)

Further Reading

There are innumerable articles on this struggle, but a good place to begin is:

BnAmericas article here http://www.bnamericas.com/news/mining/codelco-enami-exploration-project-in-ecuador-faces-bumpy-future-possible-failure

Current information can be found at DECOIN’s Facebook page, but also in these sites:

www.codelcoecuador.com

www.codelcofueradeintag.blogspot.com

www.decoin.org

Related Posts

Gachantivá follows the example of municipalities defending their territory in Colombia
AN ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER  WITH HISTORICAL BURDEN in Argentina
Urgent call to save the Nangaritza River and the Condor Mountain Range:  Ecuador under threat
LEAKAGES, POLLUTION AND SILENCED GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS in Jachal, Argentina
The Colombian government has a new strategy to limit popular consultations but communities are proving it wrong
Seeking Justice for Rape, Murder & Repression in the Mining Industry: The Hudbay Minerals/CGN lawsuits
Panorama Mine: Mapping French mining projects
En Guatemala: Ola de represión y criminalización a la resistencia pacífica contra la mina Tahoe Resources
Ecuador: Azuay en alerta ante el extractivismo minero
Hands off Intag- Municipality of Cotacachi, Ecuador, calls on world’s largest mining company to leave its territory
National and international organizations ask the Colombian Constitutional Court to stop the recoil of Popular Consultations
Comité Ambiental at the UN: Colombia should respect popular consultations
Ibagué, first capital city in Colombia to prohibit polluting mining
Press-release on the Outrage against environmental leaders in Cajamarca, Colombia – By the Youth Socio-environmental collective group of Cajamarca COSAJUCA 
Jachal, Argentina states it will not allow a covenant with darkness
Pijao and Arbeláez say No to mining and hydrocarbons
Ecuador: DECOIN win major United Nations conservation prize
Jericó and Támesis: Colombian municipalities find new ways to stay mining-free
Cumaral, Meta: Another resounding victory for life, land & water in Colombia
¿La Minería es Sustentable?
Jericó le dijo no a la minería de metales
POLITICAL DECLARATION FOR THE IX MARCHA CARNAVAL IN DEFENSE OF WATER, LIFE AND TERRITORY
SOUTHWEST ANTIOQUIA, COLOMBIA, IN ALERT FOR LARGE-SCALE MINING
Marcha Carnaval: A global day of action to protect water and life from mining
Cumarál to hold popular consultation on oil extraction in Andes foothills
Que Aprendí Consulta Popular Cajamarca Tolima | What we learn from Popular Consultations against Mining
VICTORY! Peruvian Supreme Court Acquits Máxima Acuña de Chaupe
La tragedia de El Dorado: Un salvavidas para el Rio Atrato
A New Spill of Cyanide Solution in Jáchal, Argentina takes villagers to request a Popular Consultation
The women behind El Salvador’s historic environmental victory- AWID
Colossal Result in Cajamarca, Colombia Regarding Mining: building on the debate
Cajamarca: Central Colombian town bans ‘world’s largest open pit goldmine’
¿Cuáles son los efectos de la consulta popular en Cajamarca?
A Colossal Choice: Cajamarca prepares to decide whether to ban mining
No to industrial mega-mining for gold in French Guiana! Non à la méga-mine d’or industrielle en Guyane!  ¡No a la mega mina de oro en la Guayana Francesa!
Resistance, exchange, (post)extractivism: YLNM Coordinators meet in Galicia- in photos
New map shows how Latin American women are resisting violent extractivism
Cabrera: New Popular Consultation wins over mining in Colombia
Ecuador’s ‘progressive’ extractivism – mining, ecocide and the silencing of dissent
Persecution Persists of Shuar Indigenous Leaders in Ecuador
Origins of the mining conflict in Nankints, Ecuador

Origins of the mining conflict in Nankints, Ecuador

  • Written on: 23 February 2017
  • Posted under: Videos
Declaration on the assassination of Aldemar Parra Garcia
‘Together we are the inextinguishable fever’: Ecuadorean Government ends attempt to close Acción Ecologica
Aldemar Parra Garcia: Community leader and mining critic assassinated in Cesar, Colombia
Urgent Action to stop double persecution against Shuar communities and Accion Ecologica NGO in Ecuador
Dozens of International Organizations and Networks Call for an End to State of Emergency and Militarization in Ecuador’s Southern Amazon
Cajamarca’s Popular Referendum on Mining- An Update from Colombia
The Struggle Between Ecuador’s Indigenous Shuar and the Mega-Mining Project That’s Displacing Them
Proyecto minero chino genera convulsión en territorio Shuar en la Parroquia Panantza San Carlos, Morona Santiago
Cajamarca: Popular Referendum on mining irresponsibly arranged for Sunday 27th November
BHP Billiton employees face criminal charges on Brazil dam disaster
Colombian Constitutional Court strengthens support for popular consultations on mining as referendum in Ibague, Colombia, put on hold
Support Maxima Acuna: Sign an open letter to Yanacocha mining company and the Peruvian government
Support the people of Ibague, Colombia, to have their say on mining and show the way to peace
#AxeDrax: Campaigners unite for climate justice against coal and bioenergy-fueled deforestation
Peru: Maxima Acuña and Partner Attacked by Mining Firm’s Guards
Declaratoria final del Encuentro mexicano de resistencias contra el modelo extractivo
Colombia: Support the people of Ibague to have their say on mining!
URGENT ACTION : #RIGHT2RIP : TELL AURA MINERALS TO RESPECT THE DEAD AND THE LIVING IN HONDURAS!
TWO HUNDRED INDIGENOUS U’WA OCCUPY GAS PLANT IN COLOMBIA
Environmental Defenders Met with Paramilitary Death Threats in Tolima, Colombia
NETWORK OF ENVIRONMENTAL COMMITTEES IN TOLIMA CALLS FOR INTERNATIONAL SUPPORT OVER DEATH THREATS
Me’phaa Indigenous Fight Mexicans Mining Act
Indigenous Governance and Mining in Bolivia
Ye’kwana, Sanema and Pemon Peoples’ Declaration Against Orinoco Mining Belt
The Story of Ixtepec, Mexico: Protecting Land, Establishing No Go Zones for Mining
One woman’s victory against a mining giant in Peru
Jaime Chaupe, husband of Maxima Acuña, reports gunshots fired at family home
Peruvian farmer wins 2016 Goldman Environmental Prize for fighting world’s 2nd largest gold miner to a standstill
US and Canadian Mining Companies Seek to Sue Colombia for $16.5billion
Fight with Joy: Remembering Berta Caceres

Fight with Joy: Remembering Berta Caceres

Peticion:  Mujeres denuncian que proyectos extractivos generan violencia
Ibagué will be the first city in the world to take mining to public scrutiny
Upholding Democracy: Supporting Ibague’s Popular Consultation on Mining
In the name of poverty eradication: The terrible costs of Ecuador’s extractivist policies
Colombia in focus (II): Those opposing mining are considered terrorists
Colombia in focus: Mining, destroying and displacing indigenous people
Victory as Colombia bans mining in water-rich Paramos!
To Mine or not to Mine, that is the Question – Referendum in Tolima, Colombia
Peru: ALERT Renewed attacks against Máxima Acuña de Chaupe
Ditch coal now! The global destruction caused by the UK’s coal power generation
Water and Peace for Diodora Hernandez and her Family in Guatemala
Wampis Establish First Autonomous Indigenous Government in Peru
Anti-mining protesters occupy downtown Cusco

Anti-mining protesters occupy downtown Cusco

Ditch Coal

Ditch Coal

At the Coalface: Ten more years of UK coal burning a lifetime on the ground
Report: Ecuacorriente S.A’s Mirador Project forcibly evicting communities
Impactos De La Industria Mineria Sobre Los  Derechos De La Mujeres En Latinoamerica
The Path of the Anacondas: Protecting the Amazon-Andes-Atlantic Corridor
‘Cowfunding’: Support the Acuña-Chaupe Family to protect their lands
A Message of Solidarity to the People of Mariana, Brazil
Peru – Mining and Human Rights Defenders

Peru – Mining and Human Rights Defenders

  • Written on: 10 December 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Take Action: Canadian Aura Minerals Inc. Using Threats And Illegal Detentions To Crush Protests And Expand Gold Mine Into 200-year Old Cemetery In Honduras
Yes to Life, No to Mining participates in the workshop “Mining and Energy Multinational Companies Strategies and Participation Mechanisms for Communities Defending their Territory” – Caquetá, Colombia
Peru Signs Bill to Protect 5,000sq Miles of Amazon from Mining
Solidaridad internacional con el Frente de Mujeres defensoras de la Pachamama ante ataque de la fuerza pública
Victory for U’wa Nation in quest to defend territory
DECLARACION PUBLICA: Por despojados de las tierras de pobladores de Tundayme para explotación minera por la empresa china EcuaCorriente S.A. (Ecsa)
Community lay bare Codelco’s impacts in Intag, Ecuador
Maxima Acuña and Elmer Campos tell the World Bank how their investment has destroyed their lives
‘Capitalism is Mother Earth’s Cancer’: World People’s Summit Issues 12 Demands
Tapping into Peru’s mining conflict

Tapping into Peru’s mining conflict

  • Written on: 09 October 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Payada pa Satan

Payada pa Satan

  • Written on: 08 October 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
El Salvador vs Pacific Rim: The Price of Saying ‘No’ to a Gold Mine
Peru: A “Long March Of Sacrifice” To Protest Mining Damage
21 Reasons not to mine copper in Intag, Ecuador

21 Reasons not to mine copper in Intag, Ecuador

Deforestation in Peru: Building a dramatic future in the Amazon and the Andean Region
Mining Company Ousted by Zapotec Community in Mexico

Mining Company Ousted by Zapotec Community in Mexico

  • Written on: 23 September 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Yaigojé-Apaporis: Colombian Constitutional Court decision to reject mining could change the history of the Amazon
Qoyllur Riti tradition could be threatened by mining exploration
Fighting Conga: an emblematic case – Perú
Antofagasta Mining Region Reflects Chile’s Inequality
#StopBeloSun

#StopBeloSun

Ecuador Victims Can Seek Compensation from Chevron, Canada Supreme Court Rules
Our Resistance, Our Hope: Unity Statement of the International People’s Conference on Mining
Court Halts Mining in Yaigoje Apaporis National Park
For the Love of Water: El Salvador’s Mining Ban

For the Love of Water: El Salvador’s Mining Ban

Collected Readings on Post-Extractivism
Intag, Ecuador: Community projects as alternatives to mining (Espanol)
Free Eduardo Mosqueda!

Free Eduardo Mosqueda!

Social Cartography: opportunities for social movements, activism and resistance in South Africa and Zimbabwe
Report: Oil Dependency and the Peruvian Amazon
Venezuelan Social Movements Rally Against State Coal Mining Decree
Perú shouts to defend their land from Tía María mining project
Colombia was part of the Global Day for Action Against Mega Mining
Mercury, contaminating agent – information leaflet
Caquetá, Colombia blocks petroleum extraction in the Andes-Amazon foothills
Local researchers from YAIA receive the Equator Initiative Prize from UNDP in the Amazon
ACTION: Stand with human rights defender Victor Cruz Chi, his family and the people of Zacualpán!
Peru: YLNM ally GRUFIDES denounces attempts to defame mining resistance
A Guide for the Defense of Water
YLNM Global Solidarity Network promotes the Great Carnival Parade in Colombia
La Lucha de Intag

La Lucha de Intag

  • Written on: 15 May 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
TAKE URGENT ACTION: Earth defender Javier Ramirez sentenced to jail
#AxeDrax: UK must end support for coal and biomass reaped from US and Colombia
Intag’s Recurrent Nightmare: Adding Up The Costs Of Ecuador’s Mineral Wars
Colombia in defense of water and the páramo high mountain ecosystems
Guatemalan Women Fight Back Against A Canadian Mining Company
Huicholes: The Last Peyote Guardians

Huicholes: The Last Peyote Guardians

  • Written on: 08 April 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Se plantea una Consulta Comunitaria para decir no a la minería en Pacto, Ecuador
Indigenous peoples of Putumayo stand firm to protect territories & way of life from mining
URGENT! POLICE ENTER MAXIMA ACUNA’S LAND AND DESTROY HER HOME FOR A THIRD TIME
The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

  • Written on: 12 March 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Honduran Organizations Demand Support for Farming Not Mining
Ecuador: NO to mining in the rainforest #LibertadparaJavierRamirez
Yaigojé Apaporis – conocimiento tradicional, el corazón en proteger la Amazonia Colombiana
Yaigojé Apaporis – traditional knowledge at the heart of protecting the Colombian Amazon
Territories Free of Mining on the Rise in Honduras
In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

  • Written on: 11 December 2014
  • Posted under: Videos
Máxima versus the U.S. mining conglomerate in Peru
Campaign Against Oil Exploitation in Peru: Pastaza Film

Campaign Against Oil Exploitation in Peru: Pastaza Film

  • Written on: 14 November 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
United in resistance – Letters spark solidarity across continents
Agriculture: Our Hope For the Future. An Interview with Mariana Gomez
Yaigoje Apaporis, threatened by gold mining in Colombia
We Can’t Drink Oil: Indigenous Peoples of Peru Speak Out

Start a Conversation. Share Words of Solidarity.

This website is about building a movement. We can only build a movement when we connect with one another. We invite you to do just that…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *