Sustainable development is failing but there are alternatives to capitalism

Originally posted on The Guardian

In the face of worsening ecological and economic crises and continuing social deprivation, the last two decades have seen two broad trends emerge among those seeking sustainability, equality and justice.

First there are the green economy and sustainable development approaches that dominate the upcoming Paris climate summit and the post-2015 sustainable development goals (SDGs). To date, such measures have failed to deliver a harmonisation of economic growth, social welfare and environmental protection.

Political ecology paradigms, on the other hand, call for more fundamental changes, challenging the predominance of growth-oriented development based on fossil fuels, neoliberal capitalism and related forms of so-called representative democracy.

The false answers of the green economy

If we look at international environmental policyof the last four decades, the initial radicalism of the 1970s has vanished.

The outcome document of the 2012 Rio+20 Summit, The Future We Want, failed to identify the historical and structural roots of poverty, hunger, unsustainability and inequity. These include: centralisation of state power, capitalist monopolies, colonialism, racism and patriarchy. Without diagnosing who or what is responsible, it is inevitable that any proposed solutions will not be transformative enough.

Furthermore, the report did not acknowledge that infinite growth is impossible in a finite world. It conceptualised natural capital as a “critical economic asset”, opening the doors for commodification (so-called green capitalism), and did not challenge unbridled consumerism. A lot of emphasis was placed on market mechanisms, technology and better management, undermining the fundamental political, economic and social changes the world needs.

In contrast, a diversity of movements for environmental justice and new worldviews that seek to achieve more fundamental transformations have emerged in various regions of the world. Unlike sustainable development, which is falsely believed to be universally applicable, these alternative approaches cannot be reduced to a single model.

Even Pope Francis in the encyclical Laudato Si’, together with other religious leaders like the Dalai Lama, has been explicit on the need to redefine progress: “There is a need to change ‘models of global development’; […] Frequently, in fact, people’s quality of life actually diminishes […] in the midst of economic growth. In this context, talk of sustainable growth usually becomes a way of distracting attention and offering excuses. It absorbs the language and values of ecology into the categories of finance and technocracy, and the social and environmental responsibility of businesses often gets reduced to a series of marketing and image-enhancing measures.”

Radical alternatives

But critique is not enough: we need our own narratives. Deconstructing development opens up the door for a multiplicity of new and old notions and world views. This includes buen vivir (or sumak kawsay or suma qamaña), a culture of life with different names and varieties emerging from indigenous peoples in various regions of South America; ubuntu, with its emphasis on human mutuality (“I am because we are”) in South Africa; radical ecological democracy or ecological swaraj, with a focus on self-reliance and self-governance, in India; and degrowth, the hypothesis that we can live better with less and in common, in western countries.

These worldviews differ sharply from today’s notion of development, challenging the dogmatic belief in economic growth and proposing in its place notions of wellbeing. They are internally diverse, but they express common fundamental values, including solidarity, harmony, diversity and oneness within nature.

Many of these form a basis for transformational politics, potentially supported by the case with Syriza in Greece and Podemos in Spain. This is what has been calledplan C, a reinvigorated bottom-up project of the commons and communal solidarity. This would be an alternative to the failed plan A (austerity) and untested, but flawed, plan B (Keynesian growth based on further indebtedness).

The inability or unwillingness of UN processes to acknowledge the fundamental flaws of the currently dominant economic and political system, and to envision a truly transformative agenda for a sustainable and equitable future, is disappointing. Even as civil society pushes for the greatest possible space within the post-2015 SDGs agenda, it must also continue envisioning and promoting fundamentally alternative visions and pathways.

Radical wellbeing notions are unlikely to becoming prevalent in the current scenario. But it is not an impossible dream. As intertwined crises increase when even the green economy fails to deliver – as it inevitably must – people everywhere will be resisting and looking for meaningful alternatives.

 

Ashish Kothari is a member of Kalpavriksh (Pune, India) and co-author ofChurning the Earth (Penguin, 2012). Alberto Acosta is professor at Flacso (Quito, Ecuador) and author of El Buen Vivir (Icaria, 2013). Federico Demaria is a member of Research & Degrowth, a researcher at ICTA UAB (Barcelona, Spain) and co-editor of Degrowth: A Vocabulary for a New Era (Routledge, 2014).

 

Related Posts

Romania, Greece, South Africa: Three victories against destructive mining
Environmental conflicts can turn into solutions- new research
CAN WE TRUST ‘GREEN GROWTH’? DIY FACT CHECK

CAN WE TRUST ‘GREEN GROWTH’? DIY FACT CHECK

  • Written on: 04 May 2018
  • Posted under: Videos
Resource Sufficiency: Moving beyond the gospel of eco-efficiency
Extracting Metals from E-Waste Costs 13 Times Less Than Mining Ore
5 Stories of Resistance and Revival from 2017

5 Stories of Resistance and Revival from 2017

Highlights from the YLNM Network in 2017

Highlights from the YLNM Network in 2017

YLNM’s 2017 pick of films and tools for mining resistance
Press Release: Frontline defenders travel to London to counter Mines and Money conference between 25-30 November
The Dark Side of Digitalization: Will Industry 4.0 Create New Raw Materials Demands? 
New Report – UN Body Urges Mining Companies To Put Safety First
Cumarál to hold popular consultation on oil extraction in Andes foothills
Press Release: Apple’s Commitment to a No-Mining Future Makes Deep Sea Mining Unnecessary
Apple promises to stop mining minerals to make iPhones — it just isn’t sure how yet
Colossal Result in Cajamarca, Colombia Regarding Mining: building on the debate
Resistance, exchange, (post)extractivism: YLNM Coordinators meet in Galicia- in photos
Safeguarding People and the Environment in Chinese Investments- A guide for community advocactes
Cabrera: New Popular Consultation wins over mining in Colombia
On International Women’s Day, Honoring Women Land and Human Rights Defenders
YLNM joins ContraMINAcción to celebrate third Meeting on Impacts of Mining, in Galicia
Community Mapping & Resistance Ghana

Community Mapping & Resistance Ghana

  • Written on: 03 February 2017
  • Posted under: Videos
No to the plunder of our territories! Yes to ICCAs— territories of life!
Breaching environmental boundaries: UN report on resource limits
Breaching environmental boundaries: UN report on resource limits
Being Human: Death, Development and Earth’s Defenders
Beneath the surface: Practical films to help communities fight mining
BASIC PRINCIPLES FOR PROTECTING YOUR COMMUNITY FROM EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
No fracking, drilling or digging: it’s the only way to save life on Earth
The Sky’s Limit: Why the Paris Climate Goals Require a Managed Decline of Fossil Fuel Production
World Conservation Congress Approves Historic Measure To Protect Indigenous Sacred Lands
Standing Rock protests: this is only the beginning
Protecting Your Community from Mining and Other Extractive Industries
ICC widens remit to include environmental destruction cases
Beautiful Rising

Beautiful Rising

Post-Growth and Post-Extractivism: Two Sides of the Same Cultural Transformation
Global Day Against Mega Mining: 4 Inspiring Stories of Resistance
Report: On Dangerous Ground- record number of environmental defenders killed in 2015
‘Responsible Extractives Summit’: Sick Joke or Serious Indictment of Industry?
Infographic: Tailings Dumping in Water Systems
Why Mining Corporations Love Trade Deals

Why Mining Corporations Love Trade Deals

TO COMBAT CLIMATE CHANGE, RESTORE LAND OWNERSHIP TO INDIGENOUS PEOPLES
REPORT: ON DANGEROUS GROUND, 3 Environmental Defenders killed every day defending their lands
2015 was the worst year on record for killings of land and environmental defenders
Three Environmental Defenders Killed Every Week in 2015
Call to action: Global Day Against Mega Mining 2016
Gender and the extractive industries: putting gender on the corporate agenda
Resource Roulette: How Deep Sea Mining and Inadequate Regulatory Frameworks Imperil the Pacific and its Peoples
Report: Investment Court System put to the test
#VideoAsEvidence

#VideoAsEvidence

  • Written on: 13 May 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Video As Evidence: Field Guide | Witness Recursos
Disobedience

Disobedience

  • Written on: 03 May 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
The Journey of Coal from Colombia to Italy: The Curse of Extractivism
Latin American organizations hope for stronger accountability of Canadian mining overseas
Even the ‘Good’ Gold Mines Are Pretty Bad
Case Studies – Inspiring Stories from the Frontlines of Climate Change
Minando la Agricultura (Resumen)
Minando la Agricultura – Infografía
(Report) Mining: Enough is Enough
In Defence of Life

In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Sister Stella Matutina – In Defence of Life

Sister Stella Matutina – In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Nnimmo Bassey – In Defence of Life

Nnimmo Bassey – In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Stephan Harding – In Defence of Life

Stephan Harding – In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Mariana Gomez Soto – In Defence of Life

Mariana Gomez Soto – In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Vandana Shiva – In Defence of Life

Vandana Shiva – In Defence of Life

  • Written on: 18 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Impacts of Mining: Gendered Impacts

Impacts of Mining: Gendered Impacts

  • Written on: 08 April 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Water is Life: Don’t UnderMine It

Water is Life: Don’t UnderMine It

  • Written on: 22 March 2016
  • Posted under: Videos
Report: UnderMining the Water Cycle
Study: Human Rights Risks in Mining
Common Ground: Securing Land Rights and Safeguarding the Earth
Ibagué will be the first city in the world to take mining to public scrutiny
Global patterns of metal extractivism, 1950–2010: Providing the bones for the industrial society’s skeleton
We need a real “Alternatives to Mining” Indaba
Roşia Montană, A New Beginning – Screening and talk on building resilient communities
To Mine or not to Mine, that is the Question – Referendum in Tolima, Colombia
World Bank lowers 2016 outlook on 37 of the 46 commodities it tracks
At the Coalface: Ten more years of UK coal burning a lifetime on the ground
Mining’s $1.4 trillion plunge is like losing Apple, Google and Exxon combined
YLNM interview at D12 Paris climate march

YLNM interview at D12 Paris climate march

  • Written on: 17 December 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
COP Out: The hollow promise of the Paris climate deal
At COP21, the people and future generations will be failed once again
COP21: Call for international recognition of rights of nature and communities
It’s time to create Annex 0!
Indigenous Peoples’ Caucus Statement to the 4th UN Forum on Business and Human Rights
Community Environmental Monitoring Guide
Rights of Nature and Mother Earth: Sowing seeds of resistance, love and change
Yes to Life and Climate Justice, No to Mining and Climate Catastrophe! (EN/FR)
Panel on Extractivism, the Law, and Human Rights
Yes to Life, No to Mining participates in the workshop “Mining and Energy Multinational Companies Strategies and Participation Mechanisms for Communities Defending their Territory” – Caquetá, Colombia
Free Trade Agreement 101

Free Trade Agreement 101

  • Written on: 17 November 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Report: How Strengthening Community Forest Rights Mitigates Climate Change
Empty promises: G20 subsidies to oil, gas and coal production
Community Rights & Resource Justice in Guinea

Community Rights & Resource Justice in Guinea

  • Written on: 12 November 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Oilwatch COP21 proposal: Annex Zero
Interviews: Festival of Resistances and Rebellions

Interviews: Festival of Resistances and Rebellions

  • Written on: 23 October 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Collected Materials: The Persecution and Violation of Earth and Human Rights Defenders
Measuring the Growth of the Global Fossil Fuel Divestment and Clean Energy Investment Movement
UK: Community opponents of planned Field House coal mine buoyed by international solidarity
Yaigojé-Apaporis: Colombian Constitutional Court decision to reject mining could change the history of the Amazon
What do you know about mining? | CATAPA – Generation Transition
Fighting Conga: an emblematic case – Perú

Fighting Conga: an emblematic case – Perú

Our Resistance, Our Hope: Unity Statement of the International People’s Conference on Mining
Sustainable development is failing but there are alternatives to capitalism
Banks, Sign the Paris Pledge, Quit Coal!

Banks, Sign the Paris Pledge, Quit Coal!

  • Written on: 02 September 2015
  • Posted under: Campaigns
Collected Readings on Post-Extractivism
Study: Tailings Dam Failures On The Rise
Community Consent Index 2015
The right to say “No”: Indigenous rights experts on FPIC
ICT’s for Feminist Movement Building
‘Our Resistance, Our Hope’: A global unity forged to resist devastation of global mining liberalization
International People’s Conference on Mining 2015: A call for global solidarity against destructive mining
Colombia was part of the Global Day for Action Against Mega Mining
What can I do on the Global Day of Action Against Mega Mining?
22 July 2015 – Global Day of Action Against Mega Mining- DÍA MUNDIAL CONTRA LA MEGAMINERÍA
Mercury, contaminating agent – information leaflet
Caquetá, Colombia blocks petroleum extraction in the Andes-Amazon foothills
Africa-UK Civil Society Letter to the Mining on Top Africa: London Summit
Local researchers from YAIA receive the Equator Initiative Prize from UNDP in the Amazon
Mining Affected Peoples to Unite at International Peoples Conference on Mining, Manila 2015
A Guide for the Defense of Water
YLNM Global Solidarity Network promotes the Great Carnival Parade in Colombia
Glencore? No More! London protestors call for end to Glencore’s mining abuses in the Philippines and worldwide
Support the Maputo Declaration on Climate Justice!
Colombia in defense of water and the páramo high mountain ecosystems
Wangan and Jagalingou Peoples defend their land from Adani’s Carmichael Coal Mine
Women‘s Perspectives on the Impact of Mining on the Right to Food
Towards environmental justice success in mining resistances:  An empirical investigation
A Healthy Relationship? Wellcome Trust’s refusal to cut ties with fossil fuel industry is unacceptable
African civil society and global allies challenge Chatham House conference on ‘Extractive Industries in Africa’
The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

  • Written on: 12 March 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
New Water Grabbing Platform Unites With Yes to Life, No to Mining
Rights of Nature Tribunals
Nnimmo Bassey says #YestoLifeNotoMining

Nnimmo Bassey says #YestoLifeNotoMining

  • Written on: 11 December 2014
  • Posted under: Videos
In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

  • Written on: 11 December 2014
  • Posted under: Videos
Wake Up Call

Wake Up Call

  • Written on: 11 December 2014
  • Posted under: Videos
Idle No More: Movement for Indigenous Sovereignty

Idle No More: Movement for Indigenous Sovereignty

  • Written on: 04 December 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
Mining affected communities around the world say ‘No to Mining’ and seek to secure No Go Areas at the IUCN World Parks Congress
Mapping Violations of Human and Environmental Rights
Campaigns Against Coal

Campaigns Against Coal

  • Written on: 24 October 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
Deep Sea Mining Campaign

Deep Sea Mining Campaign

  • Written on: 22 October 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
MiningWatch Canada: Reports
Undermining Agriculture

Undermining Agriculture

  • Written on: 12 October 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
Yes to Life, No to mining Global Precedents
Insight Shares Guides to Participatory Video
Mining & Health: A Community-Centered Health Assessment Toolkit
Eradicating ecocide – a global campaign to change the legal system
The Campaign for Fossil Fuel Divestment

The Campaign for Fossil Fuel Divestment

  • Written on: 08 October 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
The Anti-Fracking Movement

The Anti-Fracking Movement

  • Written on: 08 October 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
Pitfalls & Pipelines: Indigenous Peoples and Extractive Industries
The Gaia Foundation: Opening Pandora’s Box Report
guides for Protecting Your Community Against Mining Companies

Start a Conversation. Share Words of Solidarity.

This website is about building a movement. We can only build a movement when we connect with one another. We invite you to do just that…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *