In the name of poverty eradication: The terrible costs of Ecuador’s extractivist policies

By Carlos Zorrilla

Codelco in Junín, Intag region, Ecuador

Despite its very dark history in Latin America and Africa (1), extractivism- or the extraction of natural resources at unsustainable rates- is still being favored by self-proclaimed progressive governments, such as Ecuador and Bolivia, with the justification of ending poverty. This has become a mantra for these governments, transforming poverty eradication into an end in itself, and any means to do so is being justified. However, what makes extractivism attractive to governments is the quick easy money it can provide for inept and or corrupt governments.

This, in spite of abundant and irrefutable evidence that extractivism often backfires as a way to mitigate poverty, and more than likely ends up creating more social ills (2), such as wide scale corruption (3).

In the case of Ecuador, opening up of one of the world´s most biologically important protected areas to petroleum extraction in late 2014, the Yasuni Biosphere Reserve (4), was the icing of the extractivist cake that had been baking for a long time. Large-scale mining was part of that multi-layered cake, though it had not yet risen to the level of the petroleum industry, mainly due to a mining legislation that made it relatively expensive to mine in comparison to neighboring countries. Besides wide-scale protests against most mining projects, such as the case of Intag against a large-scale copper mine, the high taxes helped to slow down the development of mining in Ecuador- which is still the only Andean nation free of large-scale metal mines.

But the mining industry has a very long history of cajoling governments until they get their way- especially in corrupt, commodity-dependent countries, and Ecuador was no exception. Since the latest mining law was enacted by the present regime, back in 2009, there have been several modifications to the legislation that has made it much easier and cheaper for mining companies to pillage the country´s minerals. The changes have created exemptions so the mining companies will be able to, for example, avoid paying the value added tax- a tax all ordinary Ecuadorian citizens and businesses have to pay. Another change, in practical terms, did away with the Windfall tax, a tax levied on extraction of mineral resources in times of boom years. The government also eliminated many regulations and permits that companies had to comply with but which the companies considered burdensome (these are some of the basic tenets of neoliberalism). Some of these changes, it is important to note, occurred after the president categorically said that no more incentives would be allowed to favor the mining industry, and that if the mining companies did not like the country’s mining legislation, that they could go elsewhere to mine (6).

Incentives such as these can easily provoke innumerable conflicts on the ground when companies- some owned by unscrupulous individuals- invade a country looking for a quick buck in fiscally and regulatory friendly environment. The effect these decisions have are enormous, and can be felt decades later, affect hundreds of thousands of people, severely impact civil and human rights as well as create environmental nightmares that can last decades or even centuries. It is what can, and often, happens when extractivism become imperative for governments to pursue. And, in the case of large-scale mining, when it is carried out by state-owned companies in a setting where independence of power is absent or dysfunctional, the impacts can be that much more devastating.

In such cases- that is, when used by self-proclaimed progressive or leftist governments in the name of poverty alleviation and in the absence of true independence of power, all of a sudden it is acceptable to violate human rights, undermine local governments, break laws, and criminalize the protests that take place when people feel their welfare, human rights and livelihoods are at risk.

In Ecuador, the Junín copper mining project, where Chilean owned Codelco, the world’s largest copper producer, has been drilling exploratory wells in primary cloud forests for nearly a year with the full blessings and support of the Correa government, typifies many of extractivism’s evils. The exploration phase includes drilling ninety 10cm holes hundreds of meters into the subsoil to assess if the extraction of the copper is economically feasible. Given today’s sliding copper prices, that is a big IF.

The drilling is taking place in community-owned and administered land, in primary forests exceptionally biodiverse even by Latin American standards, and in the midst of pristine rivers and streams. The forest also harbor dozens of mammals and other species facing extinction, and is much more threatened than Ecuador’s Amazonian forests. To even reach the mining area the government sent in hundreds of special-forces police to overwhelm the 20 year old community resistance to mining development. Weeks before that outrage Javier Ramirez, the president of the Junín community, which has been at the front-line of the resistance, was arrested without an arrest warrant and kept in jail for 10 months before being found guilty of using violence to stop mining employees from going into the mining area. At the time of the supposed incident, according to a Belgian doctor who was attending Javier for a swollen knee, he was in bed and unable to move.

The arrest and consequent occupation and intimidation of the Intag area by hundreds of police produced the effect the government and Codelco wanted, and the company recently concluded the first of three phases of exploration. But already the environmental impacts are being felt (5). Old-growth trees in primary forests are being logged to build mining infrastructure, the community’s forest reserve and infrastructure are being arbitrarily utilized, trails used by the community ecotourism project destroyed, and water welling-up from the exploration has contaminated rivers and streams- all unthinkable in most countries. The social impacts, as in all extractive projects, were felt long before the environmental ones. These include wide-scale violations of human rights- many documented and denounced by prestigious human rights organizations (7,8).

The most painfully obvious social impact is the divisions created by the mining companies. Many people from Junín itself as well as nearby communities were seduced by the false offers of jobs and the relatively easy money and security the companies provided, bringing about deep divisions within families and friends. The social fiber of the communities is also breaking down, as social, cultural and spiritual values are slowly being replaced by the lure of individual financial well-being. Even so, and as a testament to the resilience of Intag’s agricultural communities and individuals, the resistance to this devastating project continues. In this context, it is well to remember why in spite facing such powerful forces aligned against the community, there is still so much opposition.

This is a project, after all, that would not only impact some of the most biodiverse forest on our planet and dozens of species facing extinction, but would also relocate at least four communities, increase criminal activity, provoke massive deforestation of primary forests (which, according to an environmental impact study would dry up the local climate), plus contaminate rivers and streams with heavy metals. Who, then, in their right mind would not want to be part of the opposition to stop something as devastating as this?

Economic poverty is terrible, there is no denying it. But, tragically, we keep forgetting that there are other kinds of wealth and many other kinds of poverty. Even when the desire to eradicate economic poverty is well-intentioned, if the policies adopted undermine legality, weaken democratic institutions, violate human rights, threaten human populations, affect species facing extinction, in addition to decimating sustainable economic activities, you risk creating a worse, and more enduring kind of poverty; one that will haunt future generations.

References and further readings

For more in-depth information about the human rights abuses see the documentary Javier with i Intag at http://bit.ly/1mCtEdP

1. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/…/282450Natural0resourc…
2. http://earth.columbia.edu/…/dir…/pubs/EuroEconReview2001.pdf
3. http://www.theguardian.com/…/the-global-extraction-industry…
4. http://www.theguardian.com/…/ecuador-approves-yasuni-amazon…
5. https://www.facebook.com/media/set/…
6. http://lta.reuters.com/…/businessnews/idltakbn0ny2ch20150513
7. http://bit.ly/1OVd9TX
8. http://bit.ly/1QgGMDl

Related Posts

Elementos para proteger a su comunidad de las industrias extractiva
Pregunta sobre minería en la Consulta y Referendum llevada a cabo en Ecuador el 4 de febrero 2018
The False Dilemma of Popular Consultations in Colombia
Arracacha: people of Cajamarca and Colombian businesses show there’s prosperity without mining
Gachantivá follows the example of municipalities defending their territory in Colombia
AN ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER  WITH HISTORICAL BURDEN in Argentina
Urgent call to save the Nangaritza River and the Condor Mountain Range:  Ecuador under threat
LEAKAGES, POLLUTION AND SILENCED GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS in Jachal, Argentina
The Colombian government has a new strategy to limit popular consultations but communities are proving it wrong
Seeking Justice for Rape, Murder & Repression in the Mining Industry: The Hudbay Minerals/CGN lawsuits
Panorama Mine: Mapping French mining projects
En Guatemala: Ola de represión y criminalización a la resistencia pacífica contra la mina Tahoe Resources
Ecuador: Azuay en alerta ante el extractivismo minero
Hands off Intag- Municipality of Cotacachi, Ecuador, calls on world’s largest mining company to leave its territory
National and international organizations ask the Colombian Constitutional Court to stop the recoil of Popular Consultations
Comité Ambiental at the UN: Colombia should respect popular consultations
Ibagué, first capital city in Colombia to prohibit polluting mining
Press-release on the Outrage against environmental leaders in Cajamarca, Colombia – By the Youth Socio-environmental collective group of Cajamarca COSAJUCA 
Jachal, Argentina states it will not allow a covenant with darkness
Pijao and Arbeláez say No to mining and hydrocarbons
Ecuador: DECOIN win major United Nations conservation prize
Jericó and Támesis: Colombian municipalities find new ways to stay mining-free
Cumaral, Meta: Another resounding victory for life, land & water in Colombia
¿La Minería es Sustentable?
Jericó le dijo no a la minería de metales
POLITICAL DECLARATION FOR THE IX MARCHA CARNAVAL IN DEFENSE OF WATER, LIFE AND TERRITORY
SOUTHWEST ANTIOQUIA, COLOMBIA, IN ALERT FOR LARGE-SCALE MINING
Marcha Carnaval: A global day of action to protect water and life from mining
Cumarál to hold popular consultation on oil extraction in Andes foothills
Que Aprendí Consulta Popular Cajamarca Tolima | What we learn from Popular Consultations against Mining
VICTORY! Peruvian Supreme Court Acquits Máxima Acuña de Chaupe
La tragedia de El Dorado: Un salvavidas para el Rio Atrato
A New Spill of Cyanide Solution in Jáchal, Argentina takes villagers to request a Popular Consultation
The women behind El Salvador’s historic environmental victory- AWID
Colossal Result in Cajamarca, Colombia Regarding Mining: building on the debate
Cajamarca: Central Colombian town bans ‘world’s largest open pit goldmine’
¿Cuáles son los efectos de la consulta popular en Cajamarca?
A Colossal Choice: Cajamarca prepares to decide whether to ban mining
No to industrial mega-mining for gold in French Guiana! Non à la méga-mine d’or industrielle en Guyane!  ¡No a la mega mina de oro en la Guayana Francesa!
Resistance, exchange, (post)extractivism: YLNM Coordinators meet in Galicia- in photos
New map shows how Latin American women are resisting violent extractivism
Cabrera: New Popular Consultation wins over mining in Colombia
Ecuador’s ‘progressive’ extractivism – mining, ecocide and the silencing of dissent
Persecution Persists of Shuar Indigenous Leaders in Ecuador
Origins of the mining conflict in Nankints, Ecuador

Origins of the mining conflict in Nankints, Ecuador

  • Written on: 23 February 2017
  • Posted under: Videos
Declaration on the assassination of Aldemar Parra Garcia
‘Together we are the inextinguishable fever’: Ecuadorean Government ends attempt to close Acción Ecologica
Aldemar Parra Garcia: Community leader and mining critic assassinated in Cesar, Colombia
Urgent Action to stop double persecution against Shuar communities and Accion Ecologica NGO in Ecuador
Dozens of International Organizations and Networks Call for an End to State of Emergency and Militarization in Ecuador’s Southern Amazon
Cajamarca’s Popular Referendum on Mining- An Update from Colombia
The Struggle Between Ecuador’s Indigenous Shuar and the Mega-Mining Project That’s Displacing Them
Proyecto minero chino genera convulsión en territorio Shuar en la Parroquia Panantza San Carlos, Morona Santiago
Cajamarca: Popular Referendum on mining irresponsibly arranged for Sunday 27th November
BHP Billiton employees face criminal charges on Brazil dam disaster
Colombian Constitutional Court strengthens support for popular consultations on mining as referendum in Ibague, Colombia, put on hold
Support Maxima Acuna: Sign an open letter to Yanacocha mining company and the Peruvian government
Support the people of Ibague, Colombia, to have their say on mining and show the way to peace
#AxeDrax: Campaigners unite for climate justice against coal and bioenergy-fueled deforestation
Peru: Maxima Acuña and Partner Attacked by Mining Firm’s Guards
Declaratoria final del Encuentro mexicano de resistencias contra el modelo extractivo
Colombia: Support the people of Ibague to have their say on mining!
URGENT ACTION : #RIGHT2RIP : TELL AURA MINERALS TO RESPECT THE DEAD AND THE LIVING IN HONDURAS!
TWO HUNDRED INDIGENOUS U’WA OCCUPY GAS PLANT IN COLOMBIA
Environmental Defenders Met with Paramilitary Death Threats in Tolima, Colombia
NETWORK OF ENVIRONMENTAL COMMITTEES IN TOLIMA CALLS FOR INTERNATIONAL SUPPORT OVER DEATH THREATS
Me’phaa Indigenous Fight Mexicans Mining Act
Indigenous Governance and Mining in Bolivia
Ye’kwana, Sanema and Pemon Peoples’ Declaration Against Orinoco Mining Belt
The Story of Ixtepec, Mexico: Protecting Land, Establishing No Go Zones for Mining
One woman’s victory against a mining giant in Peru
Jaime Chaupe, husband of Maxima Acuña, reports gunshots fired at family home
Peruvian farmer wins 2016 Goldman Environmental Prize for fighting world’s 2nd largest gold miner to a standstill
US and Canadian Mining Companies Seek to Sue Colombia for $16.5billion
Fight with Joy: Remembering Berta Caceres

Fight with Joy: Remembering Berta Caceres

Peticion:  Mujeres denuncian que proyectos extractivos generan violencia
Ibagué will be the first city in the world to take mining to public scrutiny
Upholding Democracy: Supporting Ibague’s Popular Consultation on Mining
In the name of poverty eradication: The terrible costs of Ecuador’s extractivist policies
Colombia in focus (II): Those opposing mining are considered terrorists
Colombia in focus: Mining, destroying and displacing indigenous people
Victory as Colombia bans mining in water-rich Paramos!
To Mine or not to Mine, that is the Question – Referendum in Tolima, Colombia
Peru: ALERT Renewed attacks against Máxima Acuña de Chaupe
Ditch coal now! The global destruction caused by the UK’s coal power generation
Water and Peace for Diodora Hernandez and her Family in Guatemala
Wampis Establish First Autonomous Indigenous Government in Peru
Anti-mining protesters occupy downtown Cusco

Anti-mining protesters occupy downtown Cusco

Ditch Coal

Ditch Coal

At the Coalface: Ten more years of UK coal burning a lifetime on the ground
Report: Ecuacorriente S.A’s Mirador Project forcibly evicting communities
Impactos De La Industria Mineria Sobre Los  Derechos De La Mujeres En Latinoamerica
The Path of the Anacondas: Protecting the Amazon-Andes-Atlantic Corridor
‘Cowfunding’: Support the Acuña-Chaupe Family to protect their lands
A Message of Solidarity to the People of Mariana, Brazil
Peru – Mining and Human Rights Defenders

Peru – Mining and Human Rights Defenders

  • Written on: 10 December 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Take Action: Canadian Aura Minerals Inc. Using Threats And Illegal Detentions To Crush Protests And Expand Gold Mine Into 200-year Old Cemetery In Honduras
Yes to Life, No to Mining participates in the workshop “Mining and Energy Multinational Companies Strategies and Participation Mechanisms for Communities Defending their Territory” – Caquetá, Colombia
Peru Signs Bill to Protect 5,000sq Miles of Amazon from Mining
Solidaridad internacional con el Frente de Mujeres defensoras de la Pachamama ante ataque de la fuerza pública
Victory for U’wa Nation in quest to defend territory
DECLARACION PUBLICA: Por despojados de las tierras de pobladores de Tundayme para explotación minera por la empresa china EcuaCorriente S.A. (Ecsa)
Community lay bare Codelco’s impacts in Intag, Ecuador
Maxima Acuña and Elmer Campos tell the World Bank how their investment has destroyed their lives
‘Capitalism is Mother Earth’s Cancer’: World People’s Summit Issues 12 Demands
Tapping into Peru’s mining conflict

Tapping into Peru’s mining conflict

  • Written on: 09 October 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Payada pa Satan

Payada pa Satan

  • Written on: 08 October 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
El Salvador vs Pacific Rim: The Price of Saying ‘No’ to a Gold Mine
Peru: A “Long March Of Sacrifice” To Protest Mining Damage
21 Reasons not to mine copper in Intag, Ecuador

21 Reasons not to mine copper in Intag, Ecuador

Deforestation in Peru: Building a dramatic future in the Amazon and the Andean Region
Mining Company Ousted by Zapotec Community in Mexico

Mining Company Ousted by Zapotec Community in Mexico

  • Written on: 23 September 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Yaigojé-Apaporis: Colombian Constitutional Court decision to reject mining could change the history of the Amazon
Qoyllur Riti tradition could be threatened by mining exploration
Fighting Conga: an emblematic case – Perú
Antofagasta Mining Region Reflects Chile’s Inequality
#StopBeloSun

#StopBeloSun

Ecuador Victims Can Seek Compensation from Chevron, Canada Supreme Court Rules
Our Resistance, Our Hope: Unity Statement of the International People’s Conference on Mining
Court Halts Mining in Yaigoje Apaporis National Park
For the Love of Water: El Salvador’s Mining Ban

For the Love of Water: El Salvador’s Mining Ban

Collected Readings on Post-Extractivism
Intag, Ecuador: Community projects as alternatives to mining (Espanol)
Free Eduardo Mosqueda!

Free Eduardo Mosqueda!

Social Cartography: opportunities for social movements, activism and resistance in South Africa and Zimbabwe
Report: Oil Dependency and the Peruvian Amazon
Venezuelan Social Movements Rally Against State Coal Mining Decree
Perú shouts to defend their land from Tía María mining project
Colombia was part of the Global Day for Action Against Mega Mining
Mercury, contaminating agent – information leaflet
Caquetá, Colombia blocks petroleum extraction in the Andes-Amazon foothills
Local researchers from YAIA receive the Equator Initiative Prize from UNDP in the Amazon
ACTION: Stand with human rights defender Victor Cruz Chi, his family and the people of Zacualpán!
Peru: YLNM ally GRUFIDES denounces attempts to defame mining resistance
A Guide for the Defense of Water
YLNM Global Solidarity Network promotes the Great Carnival Parade in Colombia
La Lucha de Intag

La Lucha de Intag

  • Written on: 15 May 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
TAKE URGENT ACTION: Earth defender Javier Ramirez sentenced to jail
#AxeDrax: UK must end support for coal and biomass reaped from US and Colombia
Intag’s Recurrent Nightmare: Adding Up The Costs Of Ecuador’s Mineral Wars
Colombia in defense of water and the páramo high mountain ecosystems
Guatemalan Women Fight Back Against A Canadian Mining Company
Huicholes: The Last Peyote Guardians

Huicholes: The Last Peyote Guardians

  • Written on: 08 April 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Se plantea una Consulta Comunitaria para decir no a la minería en Pacto, Ecuador
Indigenous peoples of Putumayo stand firm to protect territories & way of life from mining
URGENT! POLICE ENTER MAXIMA ACUNA’S LAND AND DESTROY HER HOME FOR A THIRD TIME
The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

The Legacy of Drummond in Colombia

  • Written on: 12 March 2015
  • Posted under: Videos
Honduran Organizations Demand Support for Farming Not Mining
Ecuador: NO to mining in the rainforest #LibertadparaJavierRamirez
Yaigojé Apaporis – conocimiento tradicional, el corazón en proteger la Amazonia Colombiana
Yaigojé Apaporis – traditional knowledge at the heart of protecting the Colombian Amazon
Territories Free of Mining on the Rise in Honduras
In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

In Solidarity – En Solidaridad

  • Written on: 11 December 2014
  • Posted under: Videos
Máxima versus the U.S. mining conglomerate in Peru
Campaign Against Oil Exploitation in Peru: Pastaza Film

Campaign Against Oil Exploitation in Peru: Pastaza Film

  • Written on: 14 November 2014
  • Posted under: Campaigns
United in resistance – Letters spark solidarity across continents
Agriculture: Our Hope For the Future. An Interview with Mariana Gomez
Yaigoje Apaporis, threatened by gold mining in Colombia
We Can’t Drink Oil: Indigenous Peoples of Peru Speak Out

Start a Conversation. Share Words of Solidarity.

This website is about building a movement. We can only build a movement when we connect with one another. We invite you to do just that…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *